Differential effects of adrenergic antagonists (Carvedilol vs Metoprolol) on parasympathetic and sympathetic activity: a comparison of measures
Abstract
Overview
Background. Cardiovascular autonomic neuropathy (CAN) is recognized as a significant health risk. Specific and
sensitive measures of CAN are needed for early identification and treatment to avoid complications, preferably
in the preclinical state.
Objectives. In this first of two articles, the patient cohort is described and two measures of autonomic function
are reviewed: the traditional heart rate variability (HRV)-alone method and the newer parasympathetic and sympathetic
(P&S) Method. These systems are then evaluated against known effects of the alpha/beta-adrenergic
blocker, Carvedilol, and the selective beta-adrenergic blocker, Metoprolol, on P&S activity.
Methods. Serial autonomic nervous system test data from 147 type 2 diabetes mellitus patients from eight ambulatory
clinics were analyzed. Patients were grouped according to whether a beta-blocker was (1) introduced,
(2) discontinued or (3) continued without adjustment. Group 3 served as the control. HRV-alone parameters are
computed according to standards. The P&S Method, which is a time–frequency analyses of concurrent respiratory
activity and HRV, is elucidated, as developed at MIT and Harvard Medical School (1981).
Results. The HRV-alone demonstrated that introducing either medication increased low frequency (msec2) and
standard deviation of the beat-to-beat (N-N) interval (msec), as expected. The other HRV parameter responses
were not consistent with expectations. Similar inconsistencies occurred when either medication was discontinued.
The P&S Method demonstrated that introducing or discontinuing either agent decreased or increased
sympathetic activity, respectively, according to expectations. With ongoing treatment, resting parasympathetic
activity decreased with Metoprolol but increased with Carvedilol.
Conclusion. Autonomic assessment fidelity was significantly higher with the P&S Method as validated by comparison
with previously known physiology of the cardiovascular system.
Keywords
Beta-blocker, Cardiac autonomic neuropathy, Heart rate variability, Patient outcomes, Respiratory analysis, Sympathovagal imbalance
Article Information
Disclosure
Financial support: None.
Correspondence
Dr. Joe Colombo 240 South Eighth Street Philadelphia, PA, USA 19107 joe@ans-hrv.com
Further Resources
Trending Topic
It is with pride and gratitude that we reflect on the remarkable 10-year journey of European Journal of Arrhythmia & Electrophysiology. With the vital contributions of all of our esteemed authors, reviewers and editorial board members, the journal has served as a platform for groundbreaking research, clinical insights and news that have helped shape the […]
Postural tachycardia syndrome (PoTS) is a chronic condition, predominately affecting women between the ages of 15 and 50, and prevalence is estimated to be 0.2%.1,2 It is characterised by an abnormal response by the autonomic nervous system to changes in posture causing lightheadedness ...
Catheter ablation (CA) is an invasive adjunctive therapeutic option for atrial and ventricular arrhythmias, in uncontrolled cases, following optimal medical therapy.1,2 The validation of 3D mapping and its implementation into clinical usage has been a remarkable achievement in the field ...
Welcome to the latest issue of the European Journal of Arrhythmia & Electrophysiology, the official journal of the Arrhythmia Alliance. We are honoured to present a series of compelling articles that reflect cutting-edge developments and diverse perspectives in this ever-evolving ...
Ventricular tachycardia (VT) ablation presents a challenging and growing area of focus in the realm of complex ablation, with promises of improved patient’s quality of life and clinical outcomes.1,2 Classic approaches to VT ablation centered on arrhythmia induction and ...
For decades, right ventricular pacing (RVP) has been the leading pacing technique and has been proven to be effective in treating patients with symptomatic bradycardia. However, dyssynchrony caused by non-physiological ventricular activation results in pacing-induced cardiomyopathy occurs in approximately 15% of ...
Supraventricular tachycardia (SVT) is an important cause of intrusive palpitation symptoms. This expert interview explores a nurse-led end-to-end pathway for the diagnosis, assessment and management of this condition. It was conducted at the Barts Heart Centre of Barts Health NHS ...
Highlights Failure to target and deliver durable radiofrequency lesions to all functionally critical areas has been identified as an important cause of ventricular tachycardia recurrence and is particularly challenging in deep midmyocardial or very extensive substrate where point-by-point radiofrequency ablation ...
Bradycardia, renal failure, atrioventricular nodal blockade, shock and hyperkalemia (BRASH) syndrome is a rare, often unrecognized but potentially life-threatening clinical entity that is characterized by the pentad of symptoms after which it is named. BRASH syndrome is seen most commonly ...
Radiofrequency (RF) ablation involves delivering medium-to-high-frequency alternating current, which is electrically conducted to cardiac tissue that constitutes a part of the circuit. The unipolar circuitry contains the generator, transmission lines, catheter, cardiac tissue, interposed tissue and dispersive electrode (ground pad/...
Several smart, connected and direct-to-consumer wearable devices capable of detecting cardiac arrhythmias have proliferated in the marketplace in the last decade. Increasingly, these devices are being marketed as “medical grade” in addition to “wellness” devices.1 New iterations of smartwatch and ...
Introduction: With the ever-increasing importance of home monitoring for the follow-up of cardiac implanted electronic devices (CIED), emphasised during the COVID pandemic, the workload for CIED follow-up clinics has grown exponentially. The demand on services is exceeding resource, with innovative ...
Welcome to a new issue of the European Journal of Arrhythmia & Electrophysiology. As the ongoing coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic continues to provide unprecedented challenges for electrophysiologists and other healthcare providers who manage arrhythmias, we hope you find these topical ...
Log into your Touch Account
Earn and track your CME credits on the go, save articles for later, and follow the latest congress coverage.
Sign up with an Email
Or use a .
This Functionality is for
Members Only
Explore the latest in medical education and stay current in your field. Create a free account to track your learning.
